Stocks vs. Options: Which generates better returns?

Plug in your stock idea to find options trades offering a potentially better ROI.

Learn more about the OptionFinder

QUOTES

Enter a stock ticker symbol above
to find charts, news, and analysis.

Symbol Price Change % Change
VIX 17.58 -0.48 -2.73%
PLL 38.87 -1.97 -5.07%
CAM 44.65 +0.46 +1.04%

Clear recent quotes

MARKETS

VIX 17.58 -0.48 (-2.73%)
VIX 17.58 -0.48 -2.73%
Dow (DJX) 106.25 +0.13 +0.12%
Nasdaq (NDX) 1924.43 +0.62 +0.03%
S&P 500 (SPX) 1149.99 -0.25 -0.02%
CLOSE
Stock Traders:
5 Ways That Options Can Make You a Better Stock Trader

NEW TO OPTIONS?
Visit our New to Options page to learn more.
Find out more »

10 Ways Options News Can Improve Your Stock Trades

Take your position in Disney (NYSE: DIS)

Analyzing Disney technicals and fundamentals ahead of tomorrow’s earnings release

  • Headshot of Jared Levy Jared Levy worked as a stock broker and market maker at three major U.S. exchanges and as a specialist for Fortune 1000 companies. He won an Emmy for his Wizetrade daily trader-cast videos.

by Jared Levy February 8, 2010 11:20 EST Related Symbols:

Walt Disney (NYSE: DIS) – the corporate parent of Mickey Mouse, Pixar, the newly-defunct Miramax, Disneyworld, Marvel Comics, ESPN, ABC and other iconic brands – reports earnings tomorrow. The media giant had a tough year in 2009, with earnings per share dropping 20% to 1.82 from its record high of $2.28 per share in 2008.  Additionally, total revenue was off 4% for the year.

Moving forward into 2010, with global economies hopefully continuing to stabilize, DIS hopes to bring a little more joy to its shareholders. In the works is a theme park in Shanghai, which could be a huge bet and potential payoff for DIS, as long as China remains strong (the growth picture certainly doesn’t look as strong there as once thought, as the government tightens to curtail any bubbles). The largest city in China, Shanghai has a population of more than 20 million people and growing.  It is often viewed as the center of finance and trading in China. Disney has already expanded its empire into Asia, as it already operates a park in Hong Kong.

New ABC series including Modern Family, The Middle, Flash Forward, and Cougar Town have been well-received this season and Disney’s movie divisions also have some cool looking movies in the works such as Alice in Wonderland, The Price of Persia: The Sands of Time, The Sorcerer’s Apprentice, and Toy Story 3.

As for the shares, they have been a bit choppy of late and is off three-plus dollars since hitting a new 52 week high on 12/31/2009l; that’s a drop of almost 10%.

Analysts, meanwhile, are mixed on DIS, with nine recommending it as a “strong buy,” four as a “moderate buy,” 12 as a “hold,” one “sell,” and three “strong sell.” Based on the analysts covering DIS, the consensus earnings estimate is $0.39 per share, and the high and low estimates are $0.51 and $0.34, respectively.  Personally, I think the company’s results will come in near the high end.

Technically speaking, last week the stock finally broke out of the bearish channel it was but it still remains below its 20- and 50-day simple moving averages, which are situated around $30.25 and $31.05, respectively.  The shares also appear to be drawn to support around the $29.00 level.

Daily chart of Walt Disney (DIS) since July 2009

I do not believe DIS is overbought or oversold in the near term. The downward momentum we have seen in the past couple of days seems to be normalizing, which is a good thing if you are bullish.

I also do not believe the observed volatility is abnormal. DIS has been returning to a more ‘typical’ behavioral pattern since the elevated volatility state it has experienced over the past year and a half.

The observed 30 day historical volatility of DIS is about 21% and the mean of the implied volatility for front-month options is about 33%. This elevation is typical ahead of a report and one that should be an important one for DIS.

The 200-day moving average is way down around $27.30.  In a recovery off the bottom in what is supposed to be a “bullish” market, I prefer to see stocks continue to stay above that average.

Disney, in normal situations and in a quasi-normal macro market environments (unlike the one we saw at the end of 2008 and early 2009), tends to be a relatively quiet stock around earnings.  Typically, the stock moves less than 3%, with a couple 4.5% moves here and there. That would equal a move of less than $1.20 and chances are that it will move less.

I also like the recent correction we have had in the broad market and while I feel we could go a little lower, I am comfortable with beginning to sell some at-the-money puts to begin my systematic acquisition of stock. So with that said, I am going to take a slightly aggressive position with DIS and sell the Feb 29/26 put spread for 40 cents. This spread reduces my risk down to $2.60 and gives me the potential to make 15% on my risk. If the stock drops sharply, I will consider risking a $1.00 in the trade, but only if the stock begins to break below 28.

Much of the Disney conglomerate does have a high sensitivity to economic slowdown, although some of its media properties may offer a bit of a buffer, namely movies and TV.  Buying DIS, however, is essentially placing a bet on recovery.

For more on DIS:

Sector Update: Consumer

MidnightTrader’s Analyst Notebook: DIS

Volatility Explodes in the Market, Walt Disney (DIS) Sees Call Buying

Free Webinars

OptionsHouse e-Learn Webinar Series

  • Mar 16, 4:30 - 5:30pm ET Register

    Two Traders, One Strategy Steve and Jared take a look at risk management strategies on the OH platform.

    - Presented by OptionsHouse
  • Mar 17, 6:00 - 7:00pm ET Register

    Navigating OptionsHouse Get to know the OH platform and all the tools you have at your disposal.

    - Presented by OptionsHouse
View All Webinars...